placebo - Back in Control https://backincontrol.com/tag/placebo/ The DOC (Direct your Own Care) Project Sun, 10 Sep 2023 16:49:12 +0000 en-US hourly 1 How Many More Neck Surgeries? https://backincontrol.com/how-many-more-neck-surgeries/ Sun, 10 Sep 2023 15:30:36 +0000 http://www.drdavidhanscom.com/?p=2039

One middle-aged patient sought me out in Seattle from the East Coast for a second opinion regarding his neck. He had been disabled since 2001 with chronic pain over most of his body. He had at least 10 additional symptoms of burning, aching, stabbing, and tingling that would migrate throughout … Read More

The post How Many More Neck Surgeries? first appeared on Back in Control.

The post How Many More Neck Surgeries? appeared first on Back in Control.

]]>
One middle-aged patient sought me out in Seattle from the East Coast for a second opinion regarding his neck. He had been disabled since 2001 with chronic pain over most of his body. He had at least 10 additional symptoms of burning, aching, stabbing, and tingling that would migrate throughout his body. He also was experiencing bladder urgency, balance problems, and dizziness. All of these are a result of the body being a state of flight or fight physiology (how the body functions). The medical world has come up with a new diagnosis of MUS (medically unexplained symptoms), which is not correct. The term should be MES (Medical explained Symptoms).

In 2003, a neurosurgeon performed a laminectomy of his neck. That’s an operation where the lamina or the bone over the back of the spinal cord is removed to relieve pressure. He seemed to improve for a little while. In 2005, his symptoms worsened, and in 2009, he underwent a fusion through the front of his neck between his 5th and 6th vertebrae. Again there was a slight improvement but two years later he was in my office with crippling pain throughout his whole body.

Normal studies

As I talked to him, I could see how desperate he was for relief. He also wasn’t sleeping and his anxiety and frustration were a 10/10 on my spine intake questionnaire. I couldn’t find any neurological problems on my physical exam. When I looked at his neck MRI, I could see where the two prior surgeries had been performed, but there were no pinched nerves. The alignment and stability of the vertebrae were also fine. He also had undergone several workups of his brain and the rest of his nervous system. Everything was normal.

 

Medical_X-Ray_imaging_CCR03_nevit

 

When I explained to him that I did not see a structural problem that was amenable to surgery he became understandably upset.  He was stuck on the idea that the prior surgeries had helped and that I was missing something. It didn’t matter what I said or how I explained the situation to him. He wasn’t buying it.

What I didn’t tell him was that I had also looked at his scans he had prior to undergoing each surgery. Telling a patient that they did not really need a prior surgery is a very unproductive, unpleasant interaction; I didn’t see why this patient’s prior surgeries were performed. On the first MRI of his neck, there were no bone spurs and the spinal cord was completely free. There wasn’t a structural problem that could have been corrected by surgery. On the scan before the second operation, there also wasn’t a hint of anything that could be causing any symptoms of any type.

The power of placebo

What’s difficult for patients (and physicians) to realize is that the placebo rate for any medical or surgical treatment is between 25-30% or even higher. The response and improvement is not only real but is powerful. It is the result of your body’s own healing capacity. It is a desired response, and you feel less pain.

The pain-killing effects of a placebo are reversed with Narcan, which is the drug used to reverse the effect of narcotics. There is a part of the frontal lobe of your brain that shuts off pain pathways for short periods of time. Another example is the placebo effect of cardiac medications causes the heart rhythms to actually change. Just because a prior surgery or procedure on normal age-appropriate anatomy might have been temporarily effective is irrelevant. It should have nothing to do with current decision-making. I tell my patients “If I can see it, I can fix it” and  “If I can’t see it, I can’t surgically correct it.” It’s critical to have a specific structural problem with matching symptoms before surgery becomes an option. Surgery: The Ultimate Placebo

I suggested that he take a look at the DOC website and I would be happy to explain the whole program to him in as much detail as needed. He was so angry that I didn’t think I’d hear from him again.

Early engagement

Over the next couple of months, I received a couple of emails and had a telephone conversation that seemed to go pretty well.  He was willing to engage in the DOC protocol and began some of the writing exercises. I had a second phone conversation with him a couple of weeks later that seemed to go even better. He was able to recognize that his thought of me “missing something that needed to be fixed” was an obsessive thinking pattern. I was encouraged and thought that maybe I had been able to break through his “story.”

Time went by and our third and final conversation was dismal. He couldn’t let go of the thought that “something was being missed” and that his seventh cervical vertebra was “out of alignment.” I assured him it was OK. As a surgeon, I am also quite obsessive about not missing problems that I can fix. At this point, it didn’t matter. He’d found a surgeon who was going to fuse his neck.

Injury conviction

Physicians use the term “injury conviction” to describe this phenomenon. It is the relentless pursuit of a cause for your symptoms that is well beyond reason. My concept has changed in that I feel this pattern of thinking becomes its own irrational set of neurological circuits. It is similar to phantom limb pain and my term is “phantom brain pain.” Regardless of whether the original source of pain is there, the symptoms are the same. Rational arguments have absolutely no effect.

 

donkey-1676260_1920

 

Hell

I wrote a post Anxiety and Anger: The Highway to Hell. Unfortunately, if you’re in this pattern, you’re in Hell, and the only way out is through you. The deep tragedy is that if you don’t realize you’re in Hell, you’ll remain there. I never give up, but I have learned to let go when I can’t penetrate that firewall of obsessive thinking. For those of you that have let yourself out this hole, I am open to suggestions as to what gave you the insight to move forward. Awareness is the basis of the entire DOC process and is always the first step.

I don’t know how many more tests and surgeries he’ll undergo over the next 30 years. The personal cost to him and society will be enormous.

What’s puzzling is that if any of the surgeons who’d chosen to operate on this man’s essentially normal anatomy were examined by a board examiner about their indications for his surgeries, they’d be failed immediately for giving a “dangerous answer.” It’s our medical responsibility to you to not offer risky procedures that have been documented to be ineffective.

Video: “Get it Right the First Time”

The post How Many More Neck Surgeries? first appeared on Back in Control.

The post How Many More Neck Surgeries? appeared first on Back in Control.

]]>
Harnessing the Body’s Healing Power https://backincontrol.com/harnessing-the-bodys-healing-power-the-placebo-effect/ Sun, 11 Dec 2016 15:16:37 +0000 https://backincontrol.com/?p=10083

The most powerful treatment for any disorder is engaging in practices that calm your nervous system and allows your body to heal itself. Each person has his or her unique way of accomplishing this. I was introduced to this concept in the 1980’s by Dr. Bernie Siegel’s book, Love, Medicine … Read More

The post Harnessing the Body’s Healing Power first appeared on Back in Control.

The post Harnessing the Body’s Healing Power appeared first on Back in Control.

]]>
The most powerful treatment for any disorder is engaging in practices that calm your nervous system and allows your body to heal itself. Each person has his or her unique way of accomplishing this.

I was introduced to this concept in the 1980’s by Dr. Bernie Siegel’s book, Love, Medicine and Miracles. He reviews some of literature that links stress with disease and also relates many stories of patients with terminal cancer who beat the disease. He formed a non-profit group, ECaP (Exceptional Cancer Patients). These miracles happened in the presence of widespread disease without any hope of survival. Although this has been witnessed for decades, he asked the question, “Why?” It is not just a lucky occurrence. Remarkable healing stories – Dr. Bernie Siegel

 

berniestillframe

 

The destructive power of anger

The same principles hold true for the healing that occurs in the DOC process. It is not a series of steps that you undertake and you are free of pain. It is a framework that organizes your thinking and clears the air so you can figure out your own next steps. Somewhere in the midst of quieting down, my patients unconsciously connect with the core of who they are and allow themselves to heal.

Being trapped causes frustration and anger. Anger disconnects you in almost every direction and adversely alters your body’s chemistry so all of your cells (organs) are bathed in stress chemicals. Some things that trap us are:

  • Our thoughts
  • Anxiety
  • Unpleasant work environment
  • Abusive home situation
  • Uncomfortable/ painful physical sensations
  • Too little money
  • Not being able to meet basic daily obligations – always behind
  • Random medical treatments

Most of these problems are not solvable, so as your legitimate frustrations continue, so will the chemical assault on your body. You cannot connect with your body’s capacity to heal in this adverse physiological environment. You can   train yourself to alter this primitive survival response.

Placebo

Placebo is a term that has been incorrectly presented to both doctors and patients. It is felt that if a patient responds to a placebo, then there clearly must not be a problem. Really? It has been shown and continues to be demonstrated that almost every medical treatment has a significant placebo component – even in the presence of the active ingredient of the drug. Also, the more invasive the treatment the more powerful the placebo effect. In other words, an injection is stronger than a pill, and a surgical procedure has even a greater placebo effect.

 

cure-1006810_1280

 

The percent of people that respond to a given treatment with a placebo effect ranges from 20 to 50% and it is consistent. I am not aware of any study that shows that the placebo effect is absent. Harnessing and  this placebo effect is what you desire. It is specific, powerful and does not have side effects or risks. There is nothing more impressive than having your immune system rally and wipe out a given cancer. All that doctors can do is to kill cells with drugs and radiation and hopefully the cancer cells are destroyed first. Occasionally surgery can completely remove it, but never in these terminal cases. The newer generation of treatments is focused more on targeting only the cancer cells.

The warts on my hands

I had a remarkable experience with my body’s healing powers in my 20’s. You can read about it in detail but after suffering with five to ten warts on both of my hands for over 10 years this disappeared forever within a week after a dermatologist told me to rub fresh Aloe Vera leaves over them. Then he told me that he thought it was a long-shot but it would work, “Because I think it is just a placebo.” I was extremely upset and angry and I can still feel what happened inside me that day. I remember feeling that “I am done with this” and I felt a deep shift occur in the middle of my body. I rubbed the Aloe Vera on my warts for a couple of times and then threw the stems out. Two weeks later I had new hands. I cannot adequately encapsulate this experience in words. It has been shown that even when patients know they are receiving a placebo it is still often effective. (2)

The drug of choice

Placebo is the drug of choice for any disease state, including chronic pain. You must get out of your own way and allow your body heal. Connecting to your own healing capacity does not carry risks or cause harm.

Unfortunately, many medical procedures do have significant risks and cause damage, even when there are no complications. I had to directly or indirectly deal with almost all of them including, stroke, blindness, paralysis and death. Addressing bad outcomes was one of  the most difficult aspects of being a surgeon. This is especially true when you wonder if you could have possibly avoided the procedure, or did my patient really understand the implications of his or her decision? There are conflicting reports but it appears that there are over 150,000 deaths annually from medical errors, which would make it the third leading cause of death behind heart disease and cancer.

One mechanism of action of placebo is that it engages the same brain mechanisms that release the body’s endorphins (natural pain killers) and ‎cannabinoids (active ingredient in marijuana). Interestingly, researchers can block the pain-killing placebo effect with a drug that blocks narcotics called naloxone.

Treatments without risk

A 2012 study recently came to my attention where lidocaine patches for LBP were compared with just the patches. It is extremely interesting in that 50% of the patients responded in both groups. Does the paper show that patients really did not have pain? “No!” It demonstrates that the healing response is stimulated by the patch. Does that mean we should be prescribing patches without the lidocaine? “No!” The risk of Lidocaine on the patch is essentially zero and adds minimal cost. A 50% response rate is excellent. (1)

It doesn’t even matter if the patients know that the “drug” is a placebo. Another “open label” placebo medication study showed a large reduction in chronic low back pain compared to the usual treatment. The mechanism of action of this effect is unclear and it does not require deception to be effective. Somehow the act of taking the pill stimulates the body’s capacity to heal. (2)

When patients heal at some point during the DOC process there is no way of knowing what aspect of it was effective and it doesn’t matter. You have connected with your body’s ability to heal and without a downside.

Heal yourself

Understand that each and every person has the capacity to access his or her own body’s ability to heal. We have observed that the vast majority of patients who engage will not only improve but thrive. Unfortunately, the anger that fires up so many symptoms is also the obstacle that blocks engagement. The major factor that portends a good outcome is willingness to be open to new ideas and then pursue them. Or, as one successful patient pointed out, “It requires a suspension of disbelief.”

  1. Hashmi, JA, et al. Lidocaine patch (5%) is not more potent then placebo in treating chronic back pain when tested in a randomized double blind placebo controlled brain imaging study. Molecular Pain (2012); 8:29-30.
  2. Carvalho C, et al. Open-label placebo treatment in chronic low back pain: a randomized controlled trial. Pain (2016); vol 0: 1-7.

 

 

 

The post Harnessing the Body’s Healing Power first appeared on Back in Control.

The post Harnessing the Body’s Healing Power appeared first on Back in Control.

]]>
Remarkable Healing Stories – Dr. Bernie Siegel https://backincontrol.com/remarkable-healing-stories/ Sun, 03 Apr 2016 14:23:22 +0000 http://www.drdavidhanscom.com/?p=7484

I have had the distinct privilege of getting to know Dr. Bernie Siegel, who is a retired pediatric general surgeon and author of several books, including Love, Medicine and Miracles. He has looked extensively at the stories of patients who are survivors of advanced cancer and documenting common traits in … Read More

The post Remarkable Healing Stories – Dr. Bernie Siegel first appeared on Back in Control.

The post Remarkable Healing Stories – Dr. Bernie Siegel appeared first on Back in Control.

]]>
I have had the distinct privilege of getting to know Dr. Bernie Siegel, who is a retired pediatric general surgeon and author of several books, including Love, Medicine and Miracles. He has looked extensively at the stories of patients who are survivors of advanced cancer and documenting common traits in these remarkable patients. There is little question that stress is a significant factor in inducing physical symptoms and comprising the body’s capacity to fight disease. His personal observations are also remarkably insightful.

I was taught from the beginning of my medical training that if a person responded to a sugar pill that meant he or she was faking it. Although this viewpoint has been refuted in multiple studies there is a still a lingering impression that something is not quite right about this kind of patient. That assumption is not only incorrect but every one of us has the capacity to respond (hopefully).  A placebo effect is the harnessing of the body’s healing power and it is the most powerful “drug” that exists. Here is an article he wrote, illustrating its power, that I wanted to share with you.

Connecting People to Healing by BERNIE SIEGEL, MD

Many years ago one of our children brought home a canvas he had decorated in his school art class. He had filled the entire canvas with the word, “ words”. As a surgeon what immediately struck me was that you can kill or cure with a sword, or scalpel. But that you could also kill or cure with words when wordswordswords  become swordswordswords. Physicians are not taught how to communicate with patients and due to their fear of being sued tell people all of the adverse side effects of therapy and never mention the benefits. Every time I hear a TV commercial mentioning how the pill being advertised can kill you I wonder why anyone would try it.

“Doing Well”

I began to realize how important a patient’s beliefs were from my experience and their experience and not their diagnosis. In a sense it is summed up by Dr. Milton Erickson writing in a patient’s chart and then excusing himself and stepping out of the office for a minute. When the patient peaked at the chart she saw, “Doing well” written there. How therapeutic.

I also learned to ask people how they would describe what they were experiencing versus their diagnosis. Then I would ask how and what in their lives fit those words if they were negative words. The words they would share, like pressure describing her pain, or failure her cancer experience led me to helping them eliminate the pressure in their life and what made them feel like a failure.

 

doing-well-is-being-well1

 

Inadvertent Hypnosis

One day, prior to performing minor surgery in my office, the patient and I got into an intense and interesting discussion. I picked up the scalpel while we were talking and made an incision. I noticed my nurse waving frantically at me. When she caught my attention she pointed at the syringe containing the local anesthetic which I had not used. I asked the patient how he was feeling and he was fine so I completed the surgery and then told him we were both hypnotized and that I had not used any local anesthetic to numb the area of surgery. Major surgery has been done under hypnosis and I have used hypnotherapists in the operating room too.

The OR environment

As I learned the power of words I began to pay more attention to what was said in the operating room. Simple things like changing an injection from feeling like a bee sting to a mosquito bite. When an anesthesiologist talked to the patient about their “going out” I would ask the patient, “When was the last time you went out on a date.” I also played music in the O.R. decades ago and was considered an explosion hazard but when everyone felt better the staff stopped complaining. Today we have studies verifying the benefits of music in shortening the time of the surgery, requiring fewer drugs and patients experiencing less pain.

During surgery I would ask my patients not to bleed and divert the blood away from the area of surgery. I was not a normal surgeon but no one is against success so if it worked it became hospital policy for which I received no credit. Before they awakened from surgery I would say, “You will wake up comfortable, thirsty and hungry.” I had to change that to “but you won’t finish what is on your plate” when my patients all began to gain weight. I couldn’t get the administrators to use the TV in patients’ rooms to prepare them for surgery with guided imagery.

But what really opened my mind to the power of words was my experience as a pediatric surgeon. To reassure children that they would not be in pain while they were undergoing surgery I would tell them while in the emergency room, “You will go to sleep when you go into the operating room.” I was shocked to have children fall asleep while they were being wheeled into the O.R. on their stretcher. One boy flipped over and went to sleep as we entered the O.R. When I turned him over for his appendectomy he awakened and said, “You told me I would go to sleep and I sleep on my stomach.” We reached a compromise.

Then I began deceiving more kids into health by rubbing them with an alcohol sponge, prior to drawing blood, and saying this will numb your skin. A third had total anesthesia while the others all had a less emotional experience and told me it didn’t work. I apologized and blamed the defective alcohol sponge.

Responding to a Known Placebo

Labeling vitamin pills, with the parent’s cooperation, reduced side effects of chemotherapy and other treatments. We relabeled the vitamins as anti-nausea, or hair growing or pain pills and the kids responded because of the faith they had in their authority figures. One woman I know was feeling nauseated after her chemo. She asked her daughter to get her a Compazine pill since she wasn’t wearing her glasses. Her daughter gave her the pill and she felt fine. Hours later, while wearing her glasses, she asked for another pill. When she saw it she told her daughter, “That’s not my Compazine that’s my anti-coagulant Coumadin.” “Well Mom it worked fine the last time I gave it you.”  They both were impressed and enjoyed the experience.

No Side Effects

The most dramatic experience I learned about came from my experience as well as medical errors due to technical mistakes. One of my patients had no side effects to radiation and the radiation therapist thought his machine was malfunctioning until he saw my name in her chart and then realized, “This is one of Siegel’s crazy patients.” When he asked her why she had no side effects she said, “I get out of the way and let it go to my tumor.”

The Radiation Machine is Broken

The examples which I found to be more impressive were when people who thought they were receiving chemotherapy were not due to an error preparing the medication and people who thought they were being radiated were not due to no radioactive material being replaced after the machine was repaired. The doctors involved felt terrible. The radiation therapy doctor said to me he had not treated anyone for a month and just discovered the problem when the radiation therapy machine underwent its monthly inspection.

I told him he didn’t realize what he was telling me. He repeated how terrible he felt. I said, “You’d have to be an idiot to not know you weren’t treating anyone. So you obviously had people experiencing side effects and shrinking tumors.” His eyes bulged and he said, “Oh my God you’re right.”

So believe in the mind-body unity and words. Our body responds to our beliefs and I’d rather lie therapeutically to a patient than give them a list of side effects of a treatment and induce all of them because of what they hear from an authority figure. When I did have to share some negative side effects I would add that they don’t happen to everyone; like everyone isn’t allergic to peanuts.

Let me close with some of my favorite stories and I don’t make any of them up.

The Power of a Hug

The cousin of my father in law’s nurse’s aide was told she was terminal with leukemia and it was a waste of time to go to receive chemotherapy which would only make her feel worse. When the aide heard this she called her cousin in North Carolina and told her to come up here because, “Doctor Siegel makes people well all the time.” She arrives and I am told about it so I admitted her to the hospital.  I sat on her bed and explained leukemia was not something I could treat but that I would ask an oncologist friend to come and see her. Then I gave her a big hug and went to call the oncologist. The oncologists I used had learned about Siegel’s crazy patients and had no problem working with them.

My oncologist friend told me he agreed with her doctor about the likely outcome but would give her treatment to make her feel there was hope. His letters to me began with, doing well, and ended with, in complete remission. She went home to drive her doctor nuts. What I heard later was that she told her cousin, “When Doctor Siegel hugged me I knew I would get well.” I also know patients who left their troubles to God and had their cancer disappear. That is called self-induced healing and not a spontaneous remission. So learn from exceptional patients about survival behavior. Ask them why they didn’t die rather than saying what doctors tend to say, “You are doing very well. Whatever you’re doing keep it up.”  Then they learn nothing from their patient. Personality characteristics and survival are inseparable.

 

senior-elderly-health-education-information-twin-cities-mn

 

You are vomiting after chemotherapy and your husband puts bags in the car so that you can throw up into the bag on the way home. One day you are feeling nauseated and ask your husband for a bag. He hands it to you; you open it and find a dozen roses from your husband. You never vomit again after receiving chemotherapy.

Last but not least remind patients of their potential. Our Creator has built survival mechanisms into all living things so we can heal wounds, alter our genes and overcome various diseases. Love your life and your body and amazing things can happen. As Ernest Holmes said, “What if Jesus was the only normal person who ever lived?” Our Creator has built survival mechanisms into all living things so we can heal wounds, alter our genes and overcome various diseases. Love your life and your body and amazing things can happen. We have the potential guilt into us. We just need to show up for practice, have faith and not fear failing. As Ernest Holmes said, “What if Jesus was the only normal person who ever lived?”

Relax

As I learned about the power of words they became my therapeutic tools. With paradox and humor, I was able to readjust people’s thoughts and feelings.

A woman I was about to operate on was in total panic before her surgery. I spent a long time trying to calm her down but nothing I said or did made a difference. So I stopped trying and wheeled her into the operating room where with a look of fear on her face she said, “Thank God all these wonderful people will be taking care of me.” I knew agreeing with her wouldn’t accomplish anything so I said, “I know these people. Ii have worked with them for years. They are not wonderful people.”  For a second she looked bewildered but then burst out laughing as did everyone in the O.R. and we all became family and fear cannot exist in the presence of love and laughter.

“I Am Never Going to Talk to You Again”

I was the police surgeon in New Haven, Connecticut for many years. One day a policeman I knew called my office. When I picked up the phone he said, “Doctor Siegel I am going to commit suicide.” I answered, “Jimmy if you commit suicide I will never talk to you again.” He hung up the phone and 15 minutes later was in my office mad as hell, shouting that he was holding a gun in his mouth and how insensitive and uncaring I was. I said, “Jimmy did you notice you’re not dead.” Then he laughed and realized I had decided to say that and it had worked. We became buddies after that.

You have a choice

I will relate stories in future posts from my own experience observing people harness their own healing potential – or not from serious diseases. I also am a witness to several patients every week who have gone pain free. That is why it is so difficult for me to watch so many patients choose to remain in pain. It is a choice. I have also watched people will themselves to death. There are over one million pain receptors per square inch in your body. There is no separation of your nervous system and body. It is simply a single unit.

 

 

 

 

The post Remarkable Healing Stories – Dr. Bernie Siegel first appeared on Back in Control.

The post Remarkable Healing Stories – Dr. Bernie Siegel appeared first on Back in Control.

]]>
Healing Power Within—Warts https://backincontrol.com/healing-power-within-warts/ Fri, 30 Nov 2012 14:04:12 +0000 http://www.drdavidhanscom.com/?p=5065

I had a lot going on during my junior year in high school. I had left home to attend a boarding school and was free from a chaotic household. It was also incredibly stressful trying to figure out what was going on and how I fit in. In the midst … Read More

The post Healing Power Within—Warts first appeared on Back in Control.

The post Healing Power Within—Warts appeared first on Back in Control.

]]>
I had a lot going on during my junior year in high school. I had left home to attend a boarding school and was free from a chaotic household. It was also incredibly stressful trying to figure out what was going on and how I fit in. In the midst of this change I developed warts all over the back of my hands. They weren’t subtle or pretty. There was always three or four of them at any given point in time. Being 17 years old with these things all over both of my hands wasn’t a great experience.

 

toad-2813036_1920

 

I tried everything to get rid of these things. I would shave them down with a razor, which I did several times a week. I tried multiple medications. I had them frozen off, but they always re-appeared. Through college and medical school, it was ongoing battle. They gradually seemed to get larger and more numerous regardless of my efforts. I became more self-conscious of them as I progressed through my medical training. I felt very awkward examining patients with what felt like were pretty disfigured hands. Of course, no one noticed them nearly as much as I did.

Orthopedic Residency

My first year of orthopedic training was stressful. I had done two years of internal medicine residency instead of the usual two years of general surgery. I was thrown right into the fire trying to catch up with the other residents. I honestly don’t know if stress was the issue, but my hands were worse with four or five large warts. I went to a skin specialist who used liquid nitrogen to burn them off. Not only was the initial burning very painful it continued burn for a couple weeks. It felt like an underground fire. I could not sleep well with the pain and I was getting increasingly frustrated. A friend gave me the name an older dermatologist who supposedly had experienced success with difficult skin problems.

My elderly dermatologist

He was nice and also really old. He looked at me and said that he didn’t think that there was much that could be done. He suggested that I rub some fresh aloe vera plant over them and that might help. I looked at him in disbelief and was now pretty despondent about ever getting rid of these things. As he handed me a couple of aloe vera stems he proceeded to say that, “I don’t really think it works. It is just probably some type of placebo effect.” At that point I become really upset. Even if the placebo effect was possible it seemed like he was even taking that option from me.

 “I’m done”

I remember standing there and I felt a profound shift deep inside of me. I recalled the recent suffering I had experienced after the last attempt of burning them off. The feeling was intense. I could almost re-experience the pain. I was “done” and simply wasn’t going to put up with it anymore. My whole being said, “No!!!”

 

climate-2584727_1920

 

I rubbed the aloe vera stems over my hands a couple of times and tossed them. Two weeks later the warts completely disappeared and six weeks later my skin looked as if they were never there. I have never experienced another wart in over 30 years. Clearly some type of immune response occurred. I don’t know what precipitated the healing response, but I could feel it and still can recall almost exactly what it felt like.

 “I’m done” – round two

The only other time I experienced that feeling was in 2002 after being stuck in a severe burnout. One of the worst parts of being depressed was feeling sorry for myself. It was endless and manifested itself in endless conversations and racing thoughts. Somehow, I became aware for the first that I was actually in a victim mode. I realized that there was no answer to being in the victim role. It was too powerful. I experienced the same deep feeling of mixed desperation and determination that I was no longer going to live this way. I was simply done. Within the next few months I began to heal. Many of my physical symptoms I had suffered with since childhood disappeared and over the next year essentially all of them resolved.

My Battle with Neurophysiological Disorder (NPD)

Also “done”

Janet had been suffering from chronic pain for years and seen by several dozen doctors. By the time she saw me, she was ready for surgery – except there was no surgical lesion that I could address. When I told her that her spine looked fine, she flipped out and began to yell at me about the whole medical profession and then some. I briefly told her about my book and website and asked her to return in a couple of weeks to discuss her options. I honestly thought I would never see her again. Much to my surprise, she not only returned, she was free of pain (and remained that way). She related a similar story to mine in that she was fed up and just going to move on without the help of doctors. She also described a deep shift that she couldn’t put into words.

Another story

I recently received this email from a reader.

Dear Dr. Hanscom,

“I was just told by a neurosurgeon today that the only way to stop my back and hopefully nerve pain in leg is surgery. I have a herniated disc at L5-S1 and he thinks it’s cartilage that is pressing on my S1 nerve. Anyway, I came back to my hotel and started googling and found your backincontrol.com site.  I really connected with it as I have started a mindfulness-based stress reduction course 2 weeks ago and am feeling some benefits already.

But what really connected me was your story on warts. When I was a young teen I also had warts on my hands. Tried the freezing and burning by physicians, but they always came back and sometimes more. One of my mom’s friends told me to steal a neighbors dishcloth and bury it in the garden, as for some reason it has worked.  I thought she was nuts!  I contemplated doing it but just couldn’t steal from my neighbors or anyone for that matter. But it got me thinking why that might work; it was using your mind. So, I started something where every night at bed I would visualize the warts going away and I have to say that I still remember the intense feeling I got in my body – something I have never again experienced.  I don’t even remember how long it took but my warts went away and never came back.

I now am trying that for my back, but not getting quite the same feeling this time. Reading your info on your Website had me motivated to try again as I really don’t want surgery if I don’t have to. I am going to follow your steps as well and already let my family know that there will be no talk about my pain.  If it works I will let you know.” Best regards, Janet

The formula??

I wish I could give you a formula to re-create the phenomenon at will. In both instances there was a deep sense of resolve that I was finished living in this manner and I said “no”. What I can’t figure out is why that feeling suddenly went so deep and was so strong. It was well beyond just willpower.

We know that the placebo response is the most powerful “drug” in existence. (1) You are simply connecting to your capacity to heal. It is the desired response. Somehow the perception of it has been distorted to be that there must not be anything really wrong if the body responds to a placebo. Every drug has a placebo effect and we also know that the bigger the intervention the greater the response. For example, and injection is stronger than a pill and surgery is even more powerful. The response tends to decrease with time. The problem is that you don’t want to incur harm while eliciting this response and unfortunately that is what often happens with spine surgery. Major adult deformity operations have a complication rate well over 50% and many of them are serious and permanent.

It has also been documented that you don’t have to “believe” placebo works to be effective. A powerful healing effect has been demonstrated even when patients are aware there are no active ingredients in the pill being administered. (2)

I have known for a while that DOC process presents creates structure and clarity for a given patient’s situation so he or she can take charge of his or her own care. There is not one answer to a complex chronic pain scenario and this is not a “how to” program. Freedom occurs when you’re able to calm down your nervous system enough to connect to your own healing powers. Each successful person has a different journey. You’re the only one with the key to unlock the door and move forward.

 

healing-1547909_1920

 

  1. Dispenza J. You are the Placebo: Making Your Mind Matter. Hay House, 2015
  2. Carvalho C, et al. Open-label placebo treatment in chronic low back pain: a randomized controlled trial. Pain (2016); 0: 1-7.

 

The post Healing Power Within—Warts first appeared on Back in Control.

The post Healing Power Within—Warts appeared first on Back in Control.

]]>